Only external comments allowed?


No spoilers will be tolerated. Thanks.

I’m noticing that recently there are a lot of blogs out there that are not allowing comments.

I am not talking about specific subjects that could be controversial, and have the comments closed to avoid flame wars or trolls. But the total removal of comments, since the beginning. I must confess I don’t understand it, as my way of approaching a blog is not as a closed book, but a place where discussion can improve the original post. Sure, when the number of comments reaches a point, there can be lots of duplicated or low level comments. But I don’t think that a reason to not allowing any. That’s why there are moderation tools.

But, ok, let’s say that I get the idea that a blog post is something complete, and nothing needs to be added to it, as it clearly expresses an idea. In that case, why are there some blogs that, instead of having their own comment system, they are linking Hacker News as a way to encourage discussion? Well, Hacker News is awesome, the community is great and there are lots of interesting discussions there. I check it frequently. But there are problems with that.

First, that you don’t have any kind of control over it. For example, I like to know what are the comments from the original writer. Sure, you can explicitly say it, but it’s not evident. I also like avatars, they help me keeping track of people writing more than one comment or in more than one post. I also like trackbacks. Maybe you prefer those details in a different way, in the exact way that HN is making them. But you cannot decide it.

You also don’t “own” the comments in any way, so if HN decides at some point to delete old comments, you can’t do anything about that. You can’t move them. You are also not notified with new comments.

And finally, my impression is that Hacker News favours the “for new content only”, making people not commenting old posts. That is probably happening everywhere, sometimes I feel that is “not proper” to comment after a couple of days has passed, or if the post is old. With HN comments I think that is exacerbated.

Again, I love Hacker News. But I think that only allowing discussion there is giving away too much.


UPDATE: As someone stated on the comments, there are also comments on Hacker News. So feel free to comment here or there! (This blog post wouldn’t be complete without this! 😀 )

9 Comments on “Only external comments allowed?

  1. A few reasons I can think of why people do this –

    1) Higher quality – comments from the average visitor tend to be lower quality than posts on HN or Proggit. This is due in part to the fact that dumb comments like “First!” or “That’s so dumb” get downvoted to oblivion.

    2) Builtin Spam filtering – feeds on the point above but HN etc have had to deal with spam for some time where joe blogging solution might not have a great solution in place to deal with it.

    • Well, about dumb comments, your duty as blogger is to remove them! 😀 Moderation tools are there for a reason

      I don’t know, in my experience the spam tools on WordPress works quite well. Of course I understand that there are other tools out there, and static site generators, etc seems to catch some attention.

      But I’ve mostly see those things in common WP themes, meaning that the access to all those things is easy.

  2. In addition, personal comment sections attract trolls. This is the reason I moderate comments on my blog. Sites with more comments and better software can get around this problem.

    • Again, I’m totally convinced of, in addition to your blog, commenting in other places, it’s just that removing comments on your site and, directly “outsorce” all that to a different place seems weird to me…

  3. I won’t comment on external sites, because they largely require accounts. It’s a shame because there could be some great feedback. In regards to spam, I put up Akismet and Hashcash. It’s prevented all spam from hitting my WordPress site.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: